For weeks I’ve wanted to pass by lower Manhattan and see this movement from an objective perspective. On Monday & Tuesday I was afforded the opportunity to do so. At first I didn’t want to engage, just observe… But that led to eavesdropping and I was effectively forced into dialogue. I quickly learned that these people are not as stupid as they’ve been made out to be. I’m going to divide my initial observations into two categories…
The Good:
- At face value, the park has been organized into impressive little self-sustainable community complete with a library, news/blogging headquarters, prayer/meditation center, sanitation department, clothing depot, food dispensary, self-service medical shelter, and sleeping supply warehouse. They’ve even gone as far as distributing free cigarettes. If you’re homeless, hungry, or unemployed, broke or bored, there’s really no better place to be right now besides Zuccotti Park.
- They’re cooking fresh meals, teaching one another history, debating politics, and more importantly, inspiring an apathetic generation to start caring about their future. This is something that I’ve personally never seen before. Although I always took interest in it, my friends never did. Having travelled a lot for my age, America seems to be the only country that its people don’t understand their own political policies, nor did they ever care to learn about them. It’s clear that this movement is looking to change that dramatically.
- Regardless of the colorful outfits, bitter/ironic signs, or their generous consumption of controlled substances, they did have individual opinions on the economy. They aren’t looking for handouts, and they know how to disagree respectfully.
So there’s no raw oyster bar, and king crab legs are not on the menu, but besides that, there is something for everyone. That leads us to the bad…
The Bad:
- There is no clean-cut set of demands or proposed solutions that everyone agrees upon. In the past, people who engaged in protests had something to the effect of a mission statement to lead people into a collective goal. This just seems like an un-organized collection of movements bundled into one, and it makes following what’s going on challenging.
- The group is divided amongst people pushing multiple agendas and they can hardly find something they agree on beyond “We want change”. Everything from cruelty to animals, legalizing Marijuana, Communism, Socialism, Anarchism, anti-Zionism, leftist ideologies, rightist ideologies, and the occasional person who contributes nothing while free-loading the supplies.
- The number of people frequenting Zuccotti Park has required internal security – and although they’re trying to be understanding, it’s difficult when conflict arrises and people are already in an argumentative state. These clashes draw a lot of attention, and watching people yell at each other is counterproductive to a successful movement.
- There are entirely too many “Donation” jars beside people exploiting the movement solely to panhandle. Don’t ever give money to people on the street. You can donate online if you want to help the actual movement – handing money to people on the street only encourages more to come out and degrade the folks who are actually contributing.
- There is entirely too much drug use – hardly a way to have your message taken seriously.
- I love drumming too, but it’s so loud and it’s drawing too many noise complaints. You’re asking to get evicted with defiant antics like drumming outside of the designated hours you’re allowed to.
- Every-day draws more free-loaders and more homeless people. While waiting on the free food line, I stood beside a man who clearly hadn’t showered in a substantial amount of time – he randomly tried talking to me, but made little sense attempting to construct sentences, so I ignored him. Meanwhile, I watched people screaming and cursing at the people preparing the food because they were hungry at that moment – not an hour from then (when dinner was scheduled to be served). They then argued with everyone on line, agitating everyone around them. Eventually security asked them to leave, but they just proceeded to the front of the line and continued to cause trouble. When the food was unwrapped and ready to serve, a Chinese protester dropped his Tibetan pamphlets and dove head first into a tray, digging his hands directly into the container and stuffing his face. It was disgusting. Completely unnecessary drama like this lead to a tray of wasted food and it’s incredibly discouraging for the people who have donated their time to prepare the meal for everyone. Security was radioed, but the damage was done, and because of his actions, a dozen people directly behind him in line will not get to eat until more is prepared.
- I’ve heard more stories about troublemakers and agitators, but I personally only saw a few. This is always a polarizing topic. You want to welcome everyone into a movement like this, but the reality is that not everyone knows how to behave, and you can’t.
Perhaps a thorough description may be a bit pre-mature as I’ve only been there for a couple of days, but I think I’ve gotten the gist of what’s going on. My initial impressions remain mixed, but I’m glad I finally made it out there. The discussions I had were interesting, and I hope people continue to engage with one another. Exchanging stories and personal experiences will help this movement grow compassionately. I also hope people continue to keep this movement peaceful, but I fear that it’s only a matter of time before the directionless messages start clouding the relevant debates. Everything going on downtown has a “V For Vendetta” feel to it, but with one too many opportunists as is always the case in a place like New York City. The potential for Occupy Wall Street to expand beyond their means could lead to a violence eruption in an attempt to contain the expansion – to some extent, it already has. Most of the protestors say they’ll cross that bridge when they get there, and with the winter imminently drawing closer, the movement is sure to subside, so maybe the timing works in its favor.
To conclude, I don’t expect most people to begin standing up for what they believe in because they rarely do. Maybe the economy has to get considerably worse before the mainstream makes their way downtown, but letting that be your catalyst only makes it a bitter journey. It’s breathtaking to see people gathering and standing up for something as an all-welcoming group. As soon as they figure out what they’re trying to tangibly accomplish, I feel that the movement will gain validity in the public eye. I initially treated the protest dismissively, but I’ll acknowledge that wasn’t fair. It takes commitment, conviction, and courage to speak your mind publicly – something I know people trapped in the corporate world (like I was) wish they could do if not for the fear of losing their jobs. That fear is being is quickly being overcome as they continue hearing the story of what happened to me amongst the thousands like me. If your job prevents you from freely expressing yourself – you’re in the wrong place.




